I got this novel from AnakDenesor on GA's segment as i am the winner! Yay congrats me !
I did read a review from AD herself, KakSha and IkaShoid about this novel.
I did read a review from AD herself, KakSha and IkaShoid about this novel.
So here is the version from me.
MY THOUGHTS
I personally like this kind of genre. From the cover itself, it already shows that this is about a person who has spilt personality. I took me one day to finished this novel because I know I need to finish it, if i stop it means I will not continue it. So, the plot of the novel is interesting. About a boy who just recently move to another school and falling in love. Later one he found out that the girl that he fall for has a dissociative identity disorder which means she has two side of her. One of her is Adira and one is Marsha. Adira is soft while Marsha is naught but she is as kind as Adira. While searching for the answer why Adira has this illness, Rafiq can not help it but fall in love. He fall in love with both of them. The story line is smooth and easy at the half of the chapter which is in a good flow until the story moved to after 8 years later. To starts 8 years later where Rafiq and still keep searching for Adira after they both separated ( hideous things happened ) So, luck on Rafiq side finally he meets again with Adira's cousin and he spilled things that happened and why Marsha appeared. Okay, so the flashback of Adira when she was 13 is good and interesting. Its sad and i cried a lil bit. But then, the writing started to get messy. The writer trying to finished this novel as fast as he can till he did not clear up most of the things. And the words suddenly become heavy and the scene of imagination become, hmmm strong and ridiculous. He is trying to make a plot twist but its just does not make sense. So, why is the mother is hating on her own child? it is true that she blame the child for the death of her husband, so she hate her, she mental and physically abuse her. The child changed 360deg, she became wild and ran away. This is not logic for a family that not searching for her. Also no details for Sasha's death and how the mom's on the wheelchair, true the child hurt her but how? we need details on this. Also Adira even have a brother who loves and very protective yet no progress of searching your own sister? Aren't you love your sister? Hmmm... that's why i said this writer is trying to finish this novel as fast as he can so he missed out all this details. And Cikgu Asif? A doctor ? same person ? The plot twist is good. But we need a lil bit details of this person too. Where is this maniac comes from and why. Where is all the dead body. What and how did they survive 13 years of crime? Do the maniac eat them or torn the skin to do furniture? ( LOL this is what happened in AHS : Asylum ) . I personally things that if this novel turn into a movie/drama would be amazing :)

review ke 3 akak baca pasal buku ni hehe
ReplyDeleterasanya buku yg sama is passed around hehehe
DeleteNak menulis pasal sakit mental kena buat research. Lagipun, benda kreatif tak boleh rushing. Harap penulis novel ni terima kritikan dan improve karya seterusnya
ReplyDeletebetul, last few chapter jadi merepek sbb penulis nak habis kan cepat
DeleteTerbaik review dari Atie.. :)
ReplyDeletethanks naim sbb baca :)
Deletedah lama betul tak membaca novel sekarang ni, last aritu rasanya novel dari Syaz je... lepas tu dah mula datang mood malas membaca
ReplyDeletesbb tu atie habiskan masa dlm satu hari sbb kalau tak, mmg tak sentuh.. i am movie freak huhuhuh
Deletekreatif ilustrasi kulit novel tu
ReplyDeleteitu betul, cantikkkkkk cover dia
DeleteNice sharing :)
ReplyDeletethanks !
DeleteUish.. kalau jadi movie ek.. Menarik juga.. Plot twist sangat..
ReplyDeletekan kak sha kan ? klu movie mmg interesting sbb org boleh tgkkkkk apa jadi.. disebabkan penulis ni tak detialskan tulisan dia, rasany jadikan movie lagi menarik
DeleteCongrats atie!
ReplyDeletethanks :)
DeleteSuch an interesting plot. By reading first lines of this review I was like " wow why none thinks of this idea for a drama?" Although it has to give some explanations of some parts. Thank you for the review. :D
ReplyDeletetrue, it would be interesting if they made into a movie
Deletewahhh mcm tu ada 2 karakter lain2?😊 cover mmg menarik👍
ReplyDeletecover dah menarik but its messy
DeleteAkak belum baca lagi buku ni, walaupun buku ni dah ada di rumah, kepunyaan anak. Nanti boleh baca bila free. :)
ReplyDeleteakak baca la, nanti nak dgr pendapat akak pula
Deletecover dia cantik. menarik juga jalan cerita dia tapi sayang penulis tak dapat nak kekal momentum cerita sampai ke penghujung.
ReplyDeletehttps://www.tiarasaphire.com/2021/02/drama-china-to-love-2020.html
this is so true.. penulis mcm nak cepat sngt habis ... then jadi merapu
DeleteWalaupun Rafiq sukakan keduanya. but still orang yang sama dengan split identity. Kiranya banyak persoalan lah ye dalam cerita ni. Tak tahu kenapa mak membenci anaknya. dan family pun tak mencari. Kalau jadikan drama, mesti menarik ceritanya untuk ditonton.
ReplyDeletefamily tak mencari tu mmg tak make sense sngt.. takkan la klu dikataakan si adik bunuh kakak, pastu mak plak benci di adik dia tanak jumpa anak dia nak marah or anything ? hmmmmm klu movie sure best
Deletewahhh nampak menarik :)
ReplyDeletetak hahaha
Deletenice review., seram x?
ReplyDeletebukan cerita hantu lol
Deletecover dia nampak lawaaa, i actually think it is your character hehe, nampak lebih kurang sama dengan header blog
ReplyDeletehahaha wowww !!! hmmm perhaps i do have split personality ahaha
DeleteI love this genre too! Tapi tak pernah mencariknya.. Huhu...
ReplyDeletehehehehe i pun dpt hadiah :)
DeleteCerita yang relates dengan psychology ni memang best sebab pasal jiwa manusia..
ReplyDeletebetul, gila bukan sejenis
Deletei see.. AD rajin jugak bt karya. mesti susah payah nk dpt 1 buku. kena bt mcm2 research
ReplyDeletebetul u.. kena pandai olah
DeleteWow psychology thriller ya?
ReplyDeleteSeems good but bad at finish. Sangat disayangkan ya Atie. Good prolog but bad epilog huhu
thats why, bad at finishing hmmm..... sangat disayangkan
Delete